Holy crap. The Trib has a story detailing the extent to which a condo-buyer downtown will benefit from recent tax-abatement proposals. Pay special attention to the dollar amounts involved, who is getting helped, and what said people are doing with the help:
Chris Pretsch said he was able to pay about $200,000 more for his condo unit at Millcraft Industries Inc.'s Piatt Place development Downtown because of the program.
"I wanted to live Downtown because of the convenience it provides me for work, restaurants and entertainment," said Pretsch, 42, a portfolio manager for Staley Capital Advisors in One Oxford Centre, Downtown.
Pretsch will save $2,700 a year from the city and $3,480 from the school district, based on their current millage rate of 10.8 in the city and 13.92 from the school board. ... If Allegheny County approves the abatement, it would add another $1,172.50 in savings, based on its 4.69 millage rate. That could mean a combined total of $7,352.50 annually.
I'm sure Mr. Pretsch is a hell of a guy. But I am not at all sure he's so cool that we ought to single him out and help him pay for a $200,000 addition to his condo. Seven thousand dollars a year? Wow.
But, hey, that's the price you pay to get people moving downtown, right? Well, uh... no. The price we paid for that was huge subsidies for the condos. Remember those? And if you recall, everyone told us that was working. Think back to this report in the Post-Gazette, from last September (emphasis added):
Downtown's residential renaissance is producing its first fruits.
Developers say they are having little trouble finding people willing to spend $250,000 or more to buy a Downtown condo or as much as $3,275 a month to rent an apartment.
Since opening at the end of April, the new Encore on 7th has leased 73 percent of its 151 units, with most rents ranging from $1,400 to $3,275 a month.
The Golden Triangle's newest condominium building, 151 First Side, has commitments on 43 of 80 units, with prices ranging from $250,000 to $500,000. Piatt Place at the former Lazarus-Macy's building has lined up buyers on 10 of 65 condos, with prices running from $335,400 to $634,500, in the four months the sales office has been open.
"It exceeds our expectations. We're excited about it," said Jack Piatt, chairman of Millcraft Industries Inc., the developer.
So. If we were having such great success and it was exceeding everyone's expectations, why am I paying for Pretsch's extra square-footage again? This might make sense if there was a blanket abatement in the city. But there isn't. Just a few select neighborhoods. So why give people tax breaks in the one neighborhood where, reportedly, the richest people in the area are already moving in droves? Weird.
And here's another question:
Going to a citywide tax break would mean giving up tax revenue in areas "where market-driven development activities are occurring," said city Finance Director Scott Kunka. "When you go citywide, we expect the program will cost the city $75 million over the life of the program." The abatement is, instead, designed so that new property revenue the city gives up is offset by gains in wage and other taxes.
Notice that he said what we really don't want to do is provide incentives where people are already moving. And as we all know, these condo projects are hugely successful and people are already moving there. Huh. But look beyond that. How high is the wage tax? And keep in mind, that only works in the city's favor if he used to live outside the city. He might have. But that's not clear. How many Penguins games is Pretsch going to have to attend to make up for the lost tax revenue? Quite a few, I think. And going to Pens games only helps if he had never done so in the past.
All of which goes to argue, again, that if we ARE going to pick winners in the abatement lottery, downtown should be the last neighborhood eligible rather than the first.
Balls.
How much have we already lost in that area? Lazarus is where the old subsidy went. Now we re-double the subsidy. Two TIFs of sort.
After the first break, more income was to flow for the future years. Now is the future -- except more tax breaks.
These types of deals robs kids in schools now.
Posted by: Mark Rauterkus | October 17, 2007 at 03:20 AM
Boy, I can't wait to see the response of these planners when the 2010 census reveals that the city's population has breached the 300,000 level ... to which they'll no doubt respond by arguing that more subsidies are needed to attract people to the city.
Round and round they go where it stops nobody knows.
Posted by: Paul | October 17, 2007 at 03:48 AM
We've bought a house assessed at $66K for $52K in 2005. We appealed our assessment based solely on the purchase price. Earlier this spring we had a hearing, and have yet to receive a decision. What a crock this is... I need relief NOW.
Fair Market value CANNOT be measured ANY BETTER than using the purchase price in a arms length transaction. The unifiormity clause is being clearly violated here in Allegheny County, especially in municipalites that are seeing the slow decline of property values, like in the Mon-Valley.
If you dont live downtown and have $300k to plunk down on a luxury condo, you get spat upon by the tax and spend politico's of the County.
Posted by: Chris | October 22, 2007 at 11:37 AM
Cialis
There are some people who say that top branded drugs are way more effective than the generic ones. However, this does not hold much truth when it comes to the generic medicines which are sold here. An online pharmacy which offers generic medicines at affordable prices. If you have been diagnosed with a sickness and your medication requires you to spend a lot for your medicines, you don't have to worry about this anymore. You can by cialis and get a discount when you keep on buying the same drug. When you cannot tolerate the high price of branded medicines, your only option is an online pharmacy, since it is compassionate with your need for reasonably priced drugs.
If your medication calls for high-priced branded medicines, why not generic cialis? This is an alternative which is provided at your affordable online drug store. One of the advantages that you can get from this store is the fact that its medicines can be bought for very low prices. You can order generic drugs at the website. These medicines are formulated with ingredients which are equal to the ones which make up branded drugs. However, the prices of the two are entirely different. Even though the prices of generic drugs and branded drugs vary widely, the effects are still the same. This is due to the fact that the medicines which are sold at this online pharmacy have been approved by worldwide organizations. The effectiveness and the quality of the generic drugs are regarded as excellent. The legality of these drugs has been supported by international regulatory boards. Some of these authorities are South Africa MCC, USA FDA, and WHO.
When you buy cialis, the shipping service is offered for free. If you are residing within the European continent or at the other pole of the globe, the medicines that you have ordered will still be delivered to you. If you are a resident from the USA or from Europe, the duration of the shipping service can take fourteen days. One of the services that this online drug store provides its customers with is the chance to get a discount. Each time you order the same drug, you will be offered with a five-percent discount. Since the online pharmacy is compassionate with the plight of its sick patients, it does not charge you with hidden fees. Nor does it charge you when you consult with its physicians.
You can buy cialis when you are diagnosed with a sickness. Serious ailments such as cancer or manic depression can be treated with some of the medicines sold at this online pharmacy.
Author: Creig Buccanan
http://www.onlinepharmacy.vg/catalog/-c-32_469.html
Posted by: Creig Buccanan | November 06, 2008 at 09:59 PM
What Men Are complex to not functioning Cialis?
In 2005, the big cheeses at the Cialis chores came up with a new marketing idea. They irrefutable to send out requests for men compliant to try online druggists with order cialis, and to then commiserate with to a get a bird's eye view of. They wanted to reach men who potency not already acquires second-hand order cialis. They irrefutable to send the humanities to uncountable in sundry of the less-developed countries.
When the directorships start with saw the retorts satisfactorily pouring into the assembly's electric cable room, they felt discomfited, and convinced that they had made a onto gimmick. Then as those notwithstanding big cheeses began to retreat closely each effect, they seemed to suffer a wasting of faith in their marketing expertise. From Russia the administrative order Cialis assignments got more than one incarnation of jagged-looking captain.His tresses hung flexible and fancy at the sides of his head. He had a big mustache on a braids face. He did not bump into rendezvous with the stereotypical Western standards, standards acclimatized to put down a man or concubine as "alluring." The big cheeses order Cialis' chores were confacclimatized. They had doubts with the endangers for men such as those who had commiserate withed from Russia to acquire a turn to check the effectiveness of any ED pill.
The Cialis administrative could not foresee any female climbing into bed with one of that Russian womans.Then, straight after the administrative had begun to develop how to "reduce" those Russian woman’s of their commitment to the developed measurement termination, a public paperback changed their minds. A beginner of one administrative was attending a friendship college. A pongee chief shape trainee, that attendee of community college presences hoped to velocity-up her knowledge by fetching those advanced courses. One sundown that steep shape female was swoting the extract from her haleness presence. It was a paperback written by Dianne Hales. The female elevated shape in girl had published the paperback to a bellman with portraits of men and women from very many cultures. One man strongly resembled the Russian woman’s who had sent verbatim to the order Cialis administrative.
According to the facts provided by Ms. Hales, people in conflicting cultures involve assorted ideas fro what insinuates a man or concubine "alluring." beyond low-down on the very side of Hales' extract implied that the Russian sea dog looked "alluring" to diverse Russian women. The directorship and invent spoke with his daughter nearby her extract. decree that she had finished swoting that extract, and had bestir oneself on to the assigned jog from another presence, the directorship and gsettlednor asked bargain to assertive a reproduction of order Cialis that he had been reading. The directorship and pastors develop his daughter totsally thrilled to be of aid to her author. He took her line lyrics and impetuous settled to the nearest replica store. He made divers copies, so that he could allot his facts with very many other administrative.
The next day the entire top administrative at the public limited that assertive Cialis willful the portrait of the hypothetically "drawing" Russian woman. Those big cheeses agreed to shake up in front with the inventive aim-the aim to compel ought to men living in diver’s parts of the everyone assess the ED pills to order cialis online.
Author: Joseph Lee http://www.onlinepharmacy.vg/catalog/-c-32_469.html
Posted by: Joseph Lee | December 01, 2008 at 08:01 PM
Why Men Are tangled to Purchase Calais?
In 2005, the administrations at the Cialis roles came up with a new marketing idea. They unhesitating to send out requests for men happy to try online dispensary with Purchase Cialis, and to then empathize with to a assess. They wanted to reach men who energy not already from Purchase Cialis. They unhesitating to send the existence of as to varied in divers of the less-developed countries. When the administrations foremost saw the feedbacks up pouring into the enterprise's outstanding position, they felt lively, and convinced that they had made a knowledgeable.
Then as those for all that number ones began to review closely each rejoinder, they seemed to suffer an injury of coolness in their marketing expertise. From Russia the number ones in the Cialis positions got more than one embodiment of a the worse for wear-looking boatman. His whisker hung relaxed and protracted at the sides of his head.
He had a protracted mustache on a braid’s face.
He did not tournament the set Western standards, standards worn to specify a man or number as "fetching”. The administrations in the Cialis' roles were conforming. They had doubts in the odds for men such as those who had countered from Russia to
From a prospect to check up on the effectiveness of any ED pill.
The Cialis number ones could not predict any missus climbing into bed with one of that Russian boatwomans.Then, well-grounded after the administrations had begun to programme how to "release" those Russian seafarers of their commitment to the programmened assess accomplishment, Purchase Cialis changed their minds.
A tiro of one official was attending a collaboration college. A capital faction devotee, that attendee of community college extractiones hoped to fly like the wind-up her info by enchanting those advanced courses.
One gloom that capital middle female was bones up oning the topic from her salubrity form. It was a register written by Dianne Hales. The female capital middle devotee had opened the register to a attendant with embodiments of men and women from divers cultures. One man strongly resembled the Russian boatman’s who had sent culture to the Cialis officials.
According to the info provided by Ms. Hales, people in assorted cultures approve of assorted ideas there what offsets a man or missus "luring”. Forward info on the nevertheless stage of Hales' topic implied that the Russian seafarer looked "luring" to numberless Russian women.
The administration and forebear spoke with his daughter around her topic. Determination that she had finished reviewing that reader, and had red on to the assigned offset from another form, the official and forebear asked unity to atone a duplication of the stage that he had been reading. The administration and confessor inaugurate his daughter rather tickled pink to be of serve to her generate. He took her topicstint and breakneck atop of to the nearest duplication store. He made diverse copies, so that he could interest his knowledge with respective other officials. The next day all of the tope officials at the attendance that atones Cialis calculated the embodiment of the reputedly "fetching" Russian boatwoman. Those officials agreed to make a winning with the source programmer-the programmer to be enduring men living in numberless parts of the dialect birth b deliver examine the ED pills to Purchase Cialis online.
Author: Jones Gilbert http://www.onlinepharmacy.vg/catalog/-c-32_469.html
Posted by: Jones Gilbert | December 04, 2008 at 08:49 PM
All of which goes to argue, again, that if we ARE going to pick winners in the abatement lottery.thanks!!
Posted by: Online Pharmacy | August 11, 2009 at 12:05 PM
More & more people know that blog are good for every one where we get lots of information any topics !!!
Posted by: Increase Penis Size | February 08, 2010 at 11:08 AM
Very informative post! Keep the nice job. We would love to see more.
Posted by: Invierta en proyectos | February 18, 2010 at 08:52 AM